Diversity, dialogue and multiculturalism in America

Manhood.

A charge into battle with teeth bared and a staunch belief that a man either returns with his shield or on it?

Clawing to the top and trudging over those who show a perceived weakness of character or physical strength?

Control?  Power?

There are certainly places and families throughout the world where these definitions still permeate the air.  In these families, reconstructing manhood is, at best, a remote goal even in this new world where the ability to care for and control a piece of land (or a woman) holds far less currency than it once did.

A man’s choice to fight against redefinition in the face of the growing power of those who were once “naturally” subordinate can be incredibly painful for everyone involved, including himself.

Having shared DNA with men who refuse to question whether the definitions of old adequately translate into this new era of humanity’s being, I intimately know the negative effects of pretending that everything is “just fine” the way it is.

Nothing is ever just fine when you’re trying to fit new pieces into an old puzzle, and there’s always a monster lurking in the background who will savagely aim to restore order at any cost.

We have all, however, experienced this world where the value and definition of manhood was simply a given.

In my recollection, if the boys learning to be men when I was growing up had any doubts about those things… well, they most certainly didn’t talk about it. Because if there was anything more defined than the strictures and symptoms of what it meant to inhabit manhood and masculinity, it was the definition of what a man was not.

Boys who read too much, wrote too much, felt too much, thought too much, preferred to be inside too much, talked about how they felt too much, wore lycra too much… they weren’t the right kind of boys.

The world I remember was a place where those hapless yet incredibly special boys could choose: they could stifle the parts of their minds that didn’t gel with the gender stereotypes or they could get pantsed in the hallway before math class.

The sons (metaphorical and biological) of these men, though, are lucky.  Because these men?  Are thought leaders, now.

When our daughter was born, my whole world shifted.

As soon as we discovered the sex of the baby, I felt a distinct responsibility to begin seriously evaluating and contextualizing gendered ideologies and behaviors.

I mean, I painted the room pink like everyone else, but only after thorough academic analysis.

My plan of action for raising my daughter is to be to be the woman I would like her to become.  Society, religion, the opposite sex, peers and others will inevitably fill gaps that I leave, and I’m okay with that.  I feel confident because I’m pretty clear on what I think it means to be a woman. Confidence is furthered by the fact that women seem to have been actively and specifically redefining womanhood in the context of liberation for, well, at least the past 100 years.

But, the boy.

Oh.  Boy.

Gender, as you know, is not the same as “sex.”  Sex is the biology of a person, and gender is a set of cultural and social values.

As it relates to the transmission of manhood to the boy, I suspect my input will be more academic in nature rather than pragmatic and useful.  In my case, I feel  fortunate that I have a partner who is both a biological and socially constructed man and happens to be the best man that I know: my husband.

Tariq naturally is the kind of man whose behavior to others, women or otherwise, is near exemplary, and he’s also a man who takes seriously his task of raising children with just the right mix of mirth and duty.

But I watch.

I watch as my husband awkwardly navigates the waters of what to pass along to the small boy he’s mentoring through manhood and what to leave quietly forgotten in the realm of his own boyhood.

I worry, too.

I worry, perhaps incorrectly, that we women are better at talking, expressing, communicating, and transmitting in the private sphere.  I worry about these brave new dads who don’t just want to be carbon copies of their own fathers but perhaps a little bit like both of their parents.

I want so badly to say, “This is what you should do…”

But, I don’t.

I can’t.

I won’t.

Because, wow, if those tables were turned, somebody gonna geta hurt reeal bad.

Instead, I just read the words of men who, like Tariq, embrace their manhood with grace and strength and can tell stories of it in ways that translate into a beautiful tapestry of the universal human experience.

They make that which seems awkward to those of us watching feel more natural and normal.  They also reassert the decisions on the part of this woman to trust that a dad can parent just as well as a mom can.

These fathers beautifully blend what it means to be a New Dad with the emergence of the New Mom, and they matter in far more significant and important ways than I think even they realize.

Maybe it’s because they’re not just writing about their lives?

They are teaching… each other, their kids, and, duh, most of all, me about the struggles of existing in a world where undisputed power must be distributed more evenly or everybody will have to deal with monsters lurking in the shadows.

So, here you go, and I’m sorry if you’re a dad and I left you out.  It’s either because you’re not posting much OR I’ve probably linked to you recently.  Or, you know, I forgot.  Because I’m a girl

  • Clark Kent’s Lunch Box (@CK_Lunchbox) : Generally cool and has great hair.  Unfortunately, picked Superman over Batman as a superior comic book hero but I’ve chosen to overlook this obvious lack of good judgment in the interest of Internet harmony.
  • The Jason Show (Either Jason is not on Twitter or we don’t follow each other… GASP!?):  Did you know the gays, they make excellent fathers?  I do.  And Jason is why.
  • Father Muskrat (@themuskrat) He treats partying at conferences like an Olympic sport in order to deflect from the fact that he’s a very gentle and thoughtful person.  Also looks a little like a serial killer and thinks I hate him.
  • Betadad (@betadad):   My number one son, and here’s why: stay at home dad, white (mostly, I mean, kind of tan-ish) dude married to an Asian American, father of twins, lived in the former Soviet Union.  This guy could write my intercultural experience blog way better than I could.  Also?  He’s in an Asian Moms group.  An.  AsianMoms.  Group.

Have fun getting to know my teachers and friends.

Now, you should tell me if you know any dads like them.

 

20 Responses to 7 Daddy Bloggers You Should Know

  1. Miss Britt says:

    I love this. The post, the guys you listed. Love.

    And I love what they’re doing with their “daddy blogging.” It really is a radical act. ;-)

  2. Kate says:

    I like the last comment “french canadian” because I am one, too, and we are a rare and excellent breed. and I agree about the other Daddy bloggers you’ve mentioned, at least the ones I know of. I’ll be reading/following the ones I haven’t yet met! Thanks FaiqaKhan!

  3. Annabelle says:

    Love this.

    So excited to check these guys out. Dad styles are as different as mom styles and I am all about learning how other people approach this crazy job.

  4. B.E. Earl says:

    I feel left out.

    I’m a daddy to four wonderful cats. “Crazy cat man”, that’s what they call me. The kind of guy who calls his cats “kids”. Yeah.

  5. Loukia says:

    Wow this post. Love. As a mom of two boys… I watch. And I teach every day. And I fall in love every day more and more with the poeple my boys are becoming. Such different pesonalities, it’s amazing. My oldest son, my reader, my thinker. My little one, sporty and spunky and social.
    Anyway. Great list of daddy bloggers! I also really like John Cave Osborne, he’s super dooper nice and a great writer, as well as Busy Dad – I think he’s a great writer.

  6. beta dad says:

    I’m honored to have made your list! I mean, it’s not like the time I was on Backpacking Dad’s Sexiest Daddybloggers list, but, eh, it’s a list.

    Psyche.

    This is a really great essay, and is extremely encouraging to me. It often seems like people are sick and tired of talking about gender norms, how they are transforming, how we should work toward their evolution, etc. They act as if it were a settled issue. Glad to see you are doing it so well!

    Thanks for the shoutout, sister!

  7. Thank you. I am both touched and honored to be included here. It is greatly appreciated. And damn how did I end up behind Beta Dad again.

    Dude ranked one above me on the Sexiest Dad Blogger list and now this. I feel like Snoopy shaking his fist at the Red Baron. ;)

  8. SciFi Dad says:

    I am humbled. Thank you.

    (And more than a little pissed that this directs people on a day where I’m writing about, of all things, the Royal Wedding. I think you did that on purpose. In my defense, life has been mind melting lately – but THAT story will start next week-ish.)

  9. SciFi Dad says:

    I am humbled. Thank you.

    (And more than a little pissed that this directs people on a day where I’m writing about, of all things, the Royal Wedding. I think you did that on purpose. In my defense, life has been mind melting lately – but THAT story will start next week-ish.)

  10. LeSombre says:

    Moi?

    Holy Poop. Thank you for including me in this list, but I gotta be honest and tell your awesome readers that I feel like a massive fraud!

    Don’t get me wrong, I am a dad, but… a blogger?

    Thank you my friend.

  11. muskrat says:

    I was with you until you dissed wearing lycra.

  12. If only Patrick still blogged…

    Can he get an Honorable Mention?

  13. Sybil Law says:

    I wholeheartedly agree with the men you chose! Well, except for the couple I don’t read – make that *didn’t* read.
    Only 80′s rock stars and various ballet dancers could pull off lycra and spandex.

  14. Slyde says:

    wow, first you stand me up in the middle of NYC, and now i’m dropped like a hot potatoe….

    The NERVE of you!

  15. Jason says:

    I am so very honored! Thank you!

    I am not on Twitter. If I were, I would most certainly follow you.

    The truth is, I’m going through a bit of a writing and reading dry spell.

    You’re the best.

  16. Normally, it would bother me that I didn’t make the cut with you.

    Then my wife reminded me that since the ring went on my finger I haven’t possessed a penis.

    Please keep me in mind for your list of “neutered bloggers.”

  17. tariq says:

    I did awkwardly navigate through the time when our son walked out wearing a pricess hat, pink high heels, and a feathered scarf.

    My answer? I bought him a tomahawk! :)

  18. Avitable says:

    Hey, I probably have kids somewhere around here. That totally qualifies me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>